KARADIN

I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here - sets up the season premise well and interesting character of Hael. A

Bad Boys - old school ep with a haunting and Dean backstory. A

Heaven Can't Wait - Cas is doing pretty well at this humanity thing, but gets back into hunting anyway. B

Slumber Party -romp with Dorothy and the Wicked Witch and Charlie. B

Devil May Care - return of always cool Abbadon can't defeat lame premise C

Rock and a Hard Place - hunting episode with offensive OC Dean barely saved by Sheriff Jodi D

Dog Dean Afternoon - Dean acts like a dog, for reals. D

I'm No Angel - all Cas wants is to get to the bunker, along the way he's fed, sexed up, tortured, killed, resurrected, then kicked out of the bunker by Zeke and Dean. F

*incidentally, Supernatural increased by 11 percent among the key demographic this week.